Daily Current Affairs Analysis

17 october 2024

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"Climate Change Hits Poorer Farmers Harder in India: FAO Report Highlights Vulnerability and Urges Policy Action"

News Explanation

he article discusses the impact of climate change on poorer farming households in India, as highlighted in a report by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations. Here's a detailed analysis:

Key Points:

1.   Vulnerability of Poor Farmers:

o    Poor households globally face a 5% loss of their total income due to heat stress and a 4.4% loss from floods in an average year.

o    The report emphasizes that poorer households are more vulnerable to climate-related stressors compared to wealthier ones. This disparity is more pronounced in the rural farming population of India.

2.   FAO Report Findings:

o    The report, titled “The unjust climate,” focuses on the adverse effects of climate change on rural populations, particularly poor, women, and youth in India.

o    Poor households' incomes are more affected by climate events like droughts and floods because they have fewer resources to mitigate these impacts. For instance, in drought conditions, they may allocate more time and resources to sustain agricultural production, leaving them with little for diversification.

3.   Structural Inequalities:

o    The vulnerability of poor households to climate impacts is attributed to structural inequalities. Poorer farmers are more exposed to climate risks because they rely heavily on agriculture without the financial or infrastructural support to buffer against adverse events.

o    The report suggests that the loss of income and productivity in such scenarios is due to limited off-farm employment opportunities and a lack of diversified income sources.

4.   Recommendations for Policymakers:

o    The FAO recommends that policy measures should aim to reduce reliance on adverse coping strategies and enhance resilience by providing off-farm employment opportunities. This can help limit the number of people pushed into poverty due to climate-related events.

o    Workforce diversification and addressing gender-based barriers in non-farm employment are crucial areas for policy intervention.

o    Expanding social security measures, especially in anticipation of extreme weather events, is suggested to provide a safety net for vulnerable households.

5.   Response from NITI Aayog:

o    NITI Aayog member Ramesh Chand responded positively, highlighting India's proactive measures to tackle climate change. India has implemented National Innovations on Climate Resilient Agriculture (NICRA), one of the first of its kind globally, which aims to address the problem through climate-smart agricultural practices.

o    Additionally, India has contingency plans for agriculture across districts and has been the first country to introduce an employment guarantee scheme to act as a social security net during such adversities.

Analysis:

The report underscores the disproportionate impact of climate change on poorer farmers, who often lack the means to withstand or recover from climate shocks. Structural inequalities, such as limited access to resources, lack of diversification, and insufficient policy support, make them more vulnerable. The FAO's recommendations stress the need for inclusive policy measures that can provide alternative livelihoods and strengthen social security.

India's proactive steps, such as the NICRA and employment guarantee schemes, show a commitment to addressing these challenges. However, to make a significant difference, these efforts need to be scaled up, ensuring that the most vulnerable sections of society are adequately supported.

Conclusion:

The FAO report highlights a critical issue—climate change disproportionately affects poorer households, exacerbating existing inequalities. Addressing this requires a holistic approach that combines policy support, economic diversification, and social security measures to build resilience among the rural poor. While India has made strides in this direction, there is a need for continuous and scaled-up efforts to mitigate the effects of climate change on the most vulnerable populations.

Mains Probable Question

"Examine the impact of climate change on poorer farming households in India as highlighted by the FAO report. What measures can be taken to mitigate these impacts, and how can policymakers address structural inequalities to improve resilience?"

Model Answer

Introduction:

Climate change has emerged as a significant threat to agriculture, particularly affecting poorer farming households who rely heavily on farming for their livelihood. A recent FAO report titled "The unjust climate" highlights how poor farmers in India face harsher impacts from climate stressors such as droughts, floods, and heat stress compared to wealthier farmers, largely due to structural inequalities and limited resources.

Impact of Climate Change on Poorer Farmers:

1.     Income Loss:

o    Poor households experience significant income losses, with the report indicating a 5% income reduction due to heat stress and 4.4% from floods on average annually. These impacts are more severe for poorer farmers who lack the financial resources to absorb these losses.

o    Climate stressors lead to reduced agricultural productivity, forcing poor farmers to allocate more time and resources to sustain their crops, thereby increasing their vulnerability.

2.     Structural Inequalities:

o    The report notes that poorer farmers are disproportionately affected due to structural inequalities, such as limited access to credit, technology, and diversified income sources. Wealthier households are better equipped to cope with and recover from climate-related shocks.

o    Gendered barriers further exacerbate the situation, as women in rural areas face additional challenges in accessing non-farm employment opportunities, compounding the economic impact on households.

3.     Dependency on Agriculture:

o    Poorer households often rely entirely on agriculture for income, making them more vulnerable to climate impacts. In case of adverse weather events, these families lack alternative income sources to buffer the financial strain, pushing them further into poverty.

Measures to Mitigate the Impact:

1.     Diversification of Income Sources:

o    To reduce dependency on agriculture, there is a need for policies that promote workforce diversification. Encouraging off-farm employment opportunities can help rural households build alternative income streams, reducing the impact of agricultural losses.

2.     Enhancing Social Security:

o    The FAO report recommends expanding social security nets to protect poorer households against income shocks caused by climate events. This includes anticipatory social protection programs that provide support during extreme weather events.

o    Strengthening existing schemes like the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) can offer a safety net for vulnerable populations.

3.     Addressing Gender Barriers:

o    Policymakers need to address gender-specific challenges by creating opportunities for women in rural areas to participate in non-farm employment. This will empower women and contribute to the overall economic resilience of households.

4.     Climate-Resilient Agricultural Practices:

o    Promoting sustainable agricultural practices and climate-resilient crops can help farmers adapt to changing climate conditions. India’s National Innovations on Climate Resilient Agriculture (NICRA) is a step in this direction, but these efforts need to be scaled up and implemented effectively across the country.

Government Response:

The Indian government, through initiatives like NICRA, has taken proactive steps to address the impacts of climate change on agriculture. NITI Aayog has highlighted India’s focus on creating a contingency plan for all agricultural districts and implementing employment guarantee schemes as a social security measure. However, continued effort is needed to expand these measures and make them more inclusive.

Conclusion:

The FAO report emphasizes that climate change exacerbates existing inequalities, disproportionately impacting poorer farmers. Addressing these challenges requires a multi-pronged approach that includes diversification of income sources, stronger social security systems, gender-sensitive policies, and sustainable agricultural practices. By implementing comprehensive and inclusive policies, India can build resilience among rural farming communities and mitigate the adverse effects of climate change on its most vulnerable populations.

MCQs for Prelims Practice